LEAF Open Farm Sunday Search

LEAF Speak Out: Difficult Questions - Beef

I’ve heard that red meat is bad for you, what would you say to defend your posi­tion as a farmer sup­ply­ing red meat?

Some peo­ple choose to eat, and real­ly enjoy red meat. Some peo­ple eat it for health rea­sons, for exam­ple some­one with anaemia might eat it to boost their iron consumption.

Eat­en in mod­er­a­tion, red meat can be an impor­tant part of our diets. Red meat does con­tain high­er sat­u­rat­ed fat than, for exam­ple chick­en, so some doc­tors rec­om­mend lim­it­ing red meat con­sump­tion to once a week and cut­ting off excess fat. Like most things, it can be good in mod­er­a­tion and as part of a bal­anced diet.

Cat­tle pro­duce a lot of methane and are bad for the envi­ron­ment, shouldn’t we move to a diet with less reliance on meat and dairy to help farming’s car­bon footprint?

Some peo­ple choose to eat, and real­ly enjoy red meat and dairy prod­ucts. Some peo­ple eat it for health rea­sons, for exam­ple some­one with anaemia might eat it to boost their iron con­sump­tion and grow­ing chil­dren drink milk to boost their cal­ci­um intake.

There are also parts of the UK where we can­not suc­cess­ful­ly grow veg­etable-based diets because soils are poor, and the cli­mate is more wet, such as in parts of Scot­land, Wales and south-west Eng­land. In these regions, farms can eas­i­ly grow grass. Humans don’t eat grass, but cows and sheep do. If we didn’t have cows and sheep in these areas, there would be lim­it­ed, or no food pro­duced from the land.

Why is beef so expensive?

The price of beef relates to the mar­ket price (sup­ply and demand), the cost of rear­ing it (its food and hous­ing) and the amount of edi­ble meat pro­duced from each ani­mal (typ­i­cal­ly 45% of a beef car­cass is ined­i­ble e.g. bones). You will often see beef on a menu that is 21- or 28- day hung, and this process also needs resources (eg labour, elec­tric­i­ty) which all adds to the cost.

Why do you leave your ani­mals out­side in the snow/​rain/​cold?

Cat­tle are out­door ani­mals and the main part of what they eat is grass, so they need to be in fields for this. Dur­ing the late autumn, win­ter and ear­ly spring, they are housed in big build­ings to keep them warmer and fed whilst there is no grass grow­ing, and also to pre­vent too much poach­ing of the ground. They are fed silage and grains in the win­ter. Silage is pick­led grass and the grains are like cow’s mues­li – a mix­ture of bar­ley, vit­a­mins and min­er­als, and soya. 

Isn’t the poach­ing that cat­tle cause bad for the soil?

Most farm­ers keep their cat­tle in build­ings in the win­ter, so that soil isn’t dam­aged dur­ing wet weath­er. Where cat­tle are kept out of doors and the field is dam­aged, the soil will recov­er over time.

Sup­port­ed by the Crop Pro­tec­tion Association

Dif­fi­cult ques­tion topics:

Gen­er­al Q&A

Arable

Beef

Dairy

Envi­ron­ment

Pigs

Poul­try

Sheep

Sporting/​hunting

Why does your bull have a ring it its nose, did that not hurt?

Are cows not bad for the envi­ron­ment — why don’t you just grow crops?

Sup­port­ed by:

Sign up to our mailing list(s)

You are now subscribed!

You are signed up to the mailing list(s) you selected.

If you no longer wish to receive emails from us, every email we send contains a link at the bottom allowing you to unsubscribe with one click. Privacy Policy.

Already have an account?

If you are already registered on this site, or you have an existing myLEAF account, then please log in below.

To register or edit your Open Farm Sunday event you will need an account. Privacy Policy.

Log in

Forgot password?

Don't have an account?

Not to worry, you can create an account by clicking the button below. Privacy Policy.

Create Account

Create an account

Creating an account is quick and easy. Simply enter your details below and we'll send you a username and password by email straight away.

To register or edit your Open Farm Sunday event you will need an account.

Your new account details will log you into both Open Farm Sunday and myLEAF. Privacy Policy.

Back to login

Account creation complete

Please check your email for a message containing your new username and password.

You can use these details to log into both Open Farm Sunday and myLEAF. Privacy Policy.

Once logged in to myLEAF for the first time, it is advisable to change your password to something memorable via the 'My Profile' page.

Back to login

Forgot password

Back to login

Forgot password

Details of your account have been sent to your email address.